The Insurance Company Says You Made Your Injuries Worse. Can They Reduce Your Settlement?

by | Nov 20, 2026 | Liability Insurance, Personal Injury, Videos

An insurance adjuster says you made your injuries worse because you could not follow a recommended treatment plan or chose a different course of care. Can that reduce your California injury settlement? The insurer may raise a failure-to-mitigate argument, but it does not automatically erase your claim or prove that you acted unreasonably. The answer depends on what happened, what options were available, and what harm could reasonably have been avoided.

What does “failure to mitigate” mean?

California’s avoidable-consequences rule generally concerns reasonable steps an injured person could take after the defendant’s wrongful conduct to limit additional harm. In a personal injury case, the party asserting that some losses could have been avoided must support that position with evidence. A disagreement about treatment is not, by itself, proof that a person acted unreasonably.

The Judicial Council’s California Civil Jury Instruction 3930 directs a jury to consider reasonable efforts and expenditures in light of the circumstances, including whether the person could make them without undue risk or hardship. The instruction does not demand perfect recovery or a particular treatment choice in every case.

Reasonable care is not the same as perfect treatment

People may face real limits after an accident. Recommended care can be expensive, transportation may be difficult, time away from work may threaten a job, or a treatment may cause side effects or conflict with other medical needs. A treating provider may change the plan, recommend an alternative, or explain that a procedure is not appropriate. Those facts can matter when someone later claims that a patient should have done more.

When practical, tell your medical provider about symptoms, concerns, cost barriers, transportation problems, and difficulty following a plan. Ask whether there are medically appropriate alternatives and keep the provider’s response. Do not guess at what is medically safe, change treatment solely because an adjuster says so, or conceal a missed appointment. The details and the medical advice matter.

How an aggravated or pre-existing condition is evaluated

An accident may aggravate a condition that existed before the collision or cause a new injury. California’s CACI No. 3927 explains that a person is not compensated for a condition that existed beforehand, but may recover for the worsening caused by the defendant’s wrongful conduct. Medical records, prior symptoms, diagnostic studies, and provider opinions may help explain what changed and when.

A pre-existing diagnosis does not, by itself, answer whether an accident caused additional harm. Likewise, a treatment gap or a different treatment choice does not automatically establish that later symptoms were avoidable. These questions are fact-specific and may require medical evidence.

Can an insurance company simply reduce your settlement?

An insurer can evaluate a claim and argue that a treatment decision affected the value of certain damages. Its position is not the same as a court finding. If a case is litigated, the party asserting failure to mitigate must prove the avoidable portion; the analysis is not an automatic penalty that wipes out every injury-related loss. Settlement negotiations may still turn on disputed evidence, medical opinions, and the insurer’s view of the claim.

Read any written evaluation carefully. Ask the adjuster to identify the specific treatment decision, records, and claimed avoidable harm in writing. A broad statement that you “made yourself worse” does not explain which damages the insurer believes could reasonably have been prevented.

Keep records that explain your treatment decisions

Save appointment notices, medical instructions, bills, insurance correspondence, and messages about care. If cost, transportation, work, side effects, or another problem affected treatment, keep documents that show the issue and the steps you took to address it. Write down dates and names after important calls. Preserve the entire letter or email, not just a screenshot of one sentence.

Do not alter records, exaggerate symptoms, or assume an insurer’s conclusion is final. If you are asked for a recorded statement or broad medical authorization, understand what is being requested before responding. The evidence should accurately show your condition, your treatment, and the real-world circumstances you faced.

Get advice before accepting a settlement

A settlement may require you to sign a release. Before agreeing, understand what claims it resolves and how the proposed amount accounts for past and future harm, medical evidence, and any disputed treatment issue. Once a release is signed, changing the agreement may be difficult. A lawyer can review the actual documents and explain how the facts may affect the claim.

The Law Office of Norman Gregory Fernandez represents injured people throughout California. Attorney Norman Gregory Fernandez has practiced law since 1997. For a free consultation, call 800-816-1529 or use the firm’s contact page. Each case depends on its facts and evidence. This article provides general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Conference room at The Law Office of Norman Gregory Fernandez
Conference room at The Law Office of Norman Gregory Fernandez.

Get Help Now

Work directly with an experienced California personal injury attorney. The Law Office of Norman Gregory Fernandez & Associates represents injured people statewide. Norman Gregory Fernandez has practiced law since 1997. The firm is not a settlement mill. Call 800-816-1529 for a free consultation or contact our office.


Related Links

Written by Norman Gregory Fernandez, Esq.

Contact Us Quickly

For a free Consultation

Or Call our 24 hour helpline NOW!

Acknowledgement

California personal injury lawyer Norman Gregory FernandezAbout Attorney Norman Gregory Fernandez

  • California personal injury lawyer and trial attorney
  • Military veteran and advocate for injured victims
  • Nearly 30 years of experience representing clients statewide

Virtual Case Signup & Processing

We can sign you up in minutes from your smartphone, laptop, desktop, or tablet anywhere in the world. No travel required. Your entire case
can be processed virtually through email, phone, video, and our online portal.
98% of cases are settled without you ever having to go to court.

No Recovery – No Fee Guaranteed

You never pay any fees unless we recover compensation for you in your California personal injury case.

Get Medical Treatment Even If You Don’t Have Insurance

In most cases, we can help you obtain medical treatment even if you do not have health insurance. Call for details at 800-816-1529.

About Our Law Firm

Watch our short intro video to learn how we help California injury victims.

10.0Norman Gregory Fernandez

10.0 - The Highest possible Avvo Rating
Recognized for excellence in legal ability & ethical standards.